St. Martin’s Press
Release Date: March 3, 2020
My Rating: 🍪🍪🍪🍪
My very first bookstagram post was a review of An Anonymous Girl by Greer Hendricks and Sarah Pekkanen, so the author pair has a special place in my heart for that reason at the very least. Their newest thriller, You Are Not Alone follows a young woman in New York who’s feeling a bit adrift. If this sounds familiar, that’s probably because it mimics the structure of their last book. I do not, however, find fault in this fact. They know this setup works for them, and I fully agree.
Shay Miller as a character did not stand out to me. Her personality seemed pretty watery and passive. The further into the narrative I got, the more I realized that this worked in her character’s storyline, but I still would have liked a little more depth so that I had a reason to really care about her. Shay is unlucky in love with her roommate who’s girlfriend has practically become a third member of their apartment. She’s been laid off from her job and then, the ultimate showstopper, she enters a subway station just in time to see a woman jump in front of the train. Shay can’t get the site of the woman’s vacant stare out of her head.
Shay becomes increasingly set on learning about the woman, Amanda. She attends her memorial service where she meets the mysterious Moore sisters. The two women are unbelievably chic and connected, and Shay, desperately needing something to cling to, becomes enamored with them.
The Moore sisters were an intriguing set of characters, used by Hendricks and Pekkanen to guide the story. I loved the way different threads from their past were woven in around Shay’s story, and did not foresee how they would tie together.
Much of this book felt like watching Shay getting helplessly tangled in a spider’s web. The actions and mannerisms of the Moore sisters make it clear that Shay is being deceived, but it was not until the conclusion that the details of what exactly was happening clicked together, and the premise for the entire setup fell into place. Thank you to St. Martin’s Press for an ARC!