
Washington Square Press
Release Date: July 7, 2015
Genre: Fiction
My Rating: 🍪🍪🍪🍪🍪
I felt an uncomfortable connection with the main character of Maybe in Another Life, Hannah Martin. The book opens on her deciding to move from New York to Los Angeles, where she grew up. Hannah has bounced around from city to city, feeling unsettled in her career and unsure where home is. Ah, the millennial dilemma, What am I doing with my life? Am I doing enough? Should I try something else?
*Followed by an abrupt reimagining of entire life.*
Hannah’s biological parents have lived in London since Hannah was in High School. They moved to allow Hannah’s sister to pursue her dancing dreams in the London ballet school. Hannah stayed behind with her best friend Gabby, and Gabby’s parents who acted like surrogates to Hannah. Moving back to L.A. with Gabby is as close to coming home as Hannah thinks she can get. She also becomes distinctly aware that Ethan, her ex-boyfriend from High School will be there. In a lovely series of banter-filled conversations, it’s clear that both girls still think he and Hannah would make a good couple.
Before I dive into plot any further, I need to address Gabby and Hannah’s friendship. Reid understands the core of a solid female friendship. The conversation between these two is so real and easy, and their comfort with each other jumps of the pages. The beautiful depiction of their camaraderie flows throughout the entirety of the book. If you can find no other reason to pick up this book, do it for this friendship.
The prospect of an entire novel based off a woman’s decision on whether or not to go home with a man at the end of the night does not appeal to me. It seems petty and shallow. Luckily, I didn’t know that was the premise of this story before I picked it up, so I had no time to question it. By the moment Hannah makes her fated choice(s) I was already fully committed to her life, her struggles, and the lovely relatability of the prose that described her. The reason I included plural “choice(s)” directly relates to the structure of the remainder of the novel. From that night with that boy, the book branches, into two parallel storylines: in one, Hannah decides to go home with Ethan (we all knew I was talking about him), and in the other, she goes home with Gabby.
I absolutely loved the two-parallel-universe-approach to this story. At first there were huge plot points that felt clichéd to me (hint: something to do with a car crash), but I got past them once each story had swept me up fully. Reid essentially gave me the pleasure of reading two books at a time, both equally alternately heart-wrenching and heart-warming. I didn’t like one more than the other, I loved them both. I was happy and sad and angry for Hannah and Gabby as they struggled through the wrenches that were thrown their way.
I thought it was particularly interesting the way that Reid had the same events play out in both storylines, but altered the characters’ reactions based off of what experiences they had had in that particular branch of the story. As the novel drew to a close, the two plots grew closer and closer together, until the same exact scene played out, but with different characters playing different roles. This was such a unique and fascinating way of storytelling, and I closed the book with my heart full of happiness for both Hannahs. Read this book.
My Rating: 🍪🍪🍪🍪🍪
Buy Maybe in Another Life on Amazon
Maybe in Another Life on Goodreads
![Treat Your S[h]elf](https://treatyourshelf.home.blog/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/bookstagram.png)








Faber and Faber